Does your Estate Sale Company Measure Up?

Here are some simple suggestions to help you find the perfect company to handle your estate:

Kim Johnson
July 6, 2021

There are plenty of reasons to feel nervous about hiring someone to literally rummage through your things and decide what’s sellable and what’s trash. And I hate to say it, but the estate sale industry is wildly unregulated in America. In one afternoon of “estate sale shopping”, you can leave one nice sale with some decent signs (or at the bare minimum an easy-to-understand shopping policy clearly posted at the entry) and end up at another one suffering from long-estranged black mold and managed by inattentive people who don’t even notice you until you’re ready to pay. Some companies are in it for the fast cash, others are experienced but lack adequate staffing or general customer service. Some have no internet, no social media presence and no email list of customers while a small number of them have their game together!

When it comes to getting your stuff sold, choosing the right company could mean the difference between your stuff being overpriced and only sold to walk-in customers or marketing to a loyal customer-base.

How did you find them?

Beware…..if you share your phone number in a bid to have companies call you about their services, expect a flood of unnecessary calls coming in. Industry regulations are non-existent, and so, too, is proper communication etiquette. I always suggest leaving an email address rather than a phone number. This allows you to do a bit of research about the company, checking their reviews and maybe even visiting one of their sales before you reach back out to them.

If they have immediate availability, this may be a red flag!

Not every company out there is a bad deal. In fact, there are many great companies and they may have just had a change in their schedule or it could be the slow time of the year. There are also some newer companies who may really know a thing or two about getting you taken care of. However, a sign of a successful company is one that is booked at least a month or two out. If they’re in high demand, maintain a seasoned and experienced staff, and know what they’re doing, they’re not running their business on the fly - they’re doing their jobs and keeping busy. If they’re booked, it’s a good sign other people trust them, too. Although, I must add, the time of the year is a big factor. The estate sale business adjusts based on the real estate market and can be somewhat seasonal. We have found January and February, as well as August, to be slower months.

Can you find them online in more than one place?

Opt for Google Searches - the ones at the top are likely paying for your clicks which means they understand basic principles of marketing. If they’re present on one “en masse” listing website but fail to have sufficient review elsewhere or a website, social media page, or professional email listed somewhere, they’re probably not the top dogs. Even worse, they could be scammers. Do your research and validate they’re going to follow-through with getting you the money you’re hiring them to bring in.

Is their website informative?

Or rather, Do they have a website which doesn't look like it’s still clinging onto life from the early 2000’s? Having a flashy website isn’t a prerequisite to providing fantastic services, but it is a sign of whether or not they handle proper advertisements to their potential customers. If they can handle a professional, modern website, they can likely handle taking good photos of their sales and managing their online marketing channels. Some questions to further consider about their online presence are:

Do they link you to client reviews?

Do they list their sales in multiple places?

Do they explain their shopping policy?

How long have they been in business?

Do they handle just estate sales, or do they provide additional services?

These are all important questions their website should be able to answer without having to ask them in person while they’re running a sale. A professional web presence will highlight the companies in it for the long-haul and the ones moonlighting for the extra cash.

Where do they advertise?

An industry standard is to advertise en masse on some central, list-style website ( or Some companies don’t even have a website and just opt to list photos en masse. If you have a lot of stuff or are expecting professional service and communication, you may want to avoid those hidden nuggets.

What are their sales like?

Take some time to visit a plethora of sales by different companies, whether they’re on your shortlist or not. Ask yourself a few basic questions:

Did they greet you?

Are their items organized and neatly organized?

Do they have sufficient staff for the size of house it is?

Do they price reasonably?

Do they have great customer service with a smile?

Are the items and home clean?

Does the home smell good?

How is the company representing the family?

How are the customers reacting to the sale experience?

When you leave a sale satisfied with the people working, imagine how their regular customers feel.

Do they service your size estate?

Not every estate sale company runs the same. From rogue franchises to one-a-weekend top notch operations, understand (and accept) that some companies may or may not be able to handle your estate size. Why? If you have a lot of small items to seel, a company with just a few part-time staffers won’t be able to do your sale justice or turn your sale around in a quick enough time frame. However, companies of every size will consider how much time and resources they’ll have to put into cleaning your home before organizing the sale. If you have too many unsellable items or trash, they will likely tell you no or offer a higher commission rate, or even an additional labor fee, for their added workload.

Are they operating in the digital realm?

A comprehensive website servicing both customers and clients isn’t cheap. Incorporating digital advertising is both time-consuming and a very impressive (yet quickly adopted industry standard) method by which to interact with customers. If a company is asking you to sign up for their email list, chances are they’re using it and it works. If they’re accepting credit cards, it’s probably because they know 70% or more of retail transactions are paid for in credit. Businesses that want to grow or remain successful aren’t denying digital and marketing trends.

Whoever you hire, you need to put your trust in them. Research your top picks and shop their sales. Be sure they’re communicating with their customers and don’t forget to read the fine print. Whatever you do, please remember - once you hire them, let them do their job. If the new hire at your company kept bothering you about how you do your job, when in reality he has no idea the experience you’ve accrued and the logic behind your decision making, how would you feel?

If you believe your company to be professional (and if you don’t, why would you hire them?), then treat them like professionals. Don't, shop your sale, and don’t ask for them to make exceptions for you. Between cleaning dirty homes and coordinating proper (and legal) disposal of crazy things found in houses to researching proper prices and marketing to customers, to managing their staff, there’s more to their job than meets the eye. Take a deep breath, relax, and trust in the company you hire. Leave them a review if you like them!

We can't wait to help you with your sale.

We've served Johnson County and the surrounding area for over six years. We're here to discuss your unique needs and can't wait to hear from you.